Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports

Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports. The right kind of cookie sheet is almost a necessity for any baker and pastry chef.

Cookie sheets are typically made from light metal or aluminum, though some cooks prefer to use dark-colored sheets as these seem to generate more even browning in the cookies on them.

As opposed to baking pans which are also rectangular but are deeper than cookie sheets, cooking surfaces that have straight sides and come with a lid, cookie pans typically have edges around all four sides.

While one might be tempted to compare these two seemingly similar items together, they really should not be used interchangeably because they tend to differ in quality and service that they provide well.

6 Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports

1. Good Cook Steel Nonstick Bakeware

good cook steel nonstick bakeware

Baking delicious cookies has never been easier than with the Good Cook Small, Medium, or Large Nonstick cookie sheet set.

The versatile and durable cookie sheet trays come with a nonstick carbon steel coating that can handle any baking concoction.

They’re even dishwasher safe so you don’t have to worry about them staying clean for your next sweet serving.

Each of the mouthwatering sizes comes in its own professional box so that you can easily wrap them up and give them as gifts and always look like a baker’s dream.

This small product is available in black, navy, grey, and red because when you want something nonstick you want it to be stylish too. The Good Cook brand non-stick cookie sheet set comes in three sizes to best suit your baking needs.

They are crafted with high-quality materials such as stainless steel, premium silicone, and aluminum that not only provide superior conductivity but also impeccable heat distribution.

No matter how well you grease traditional cookie sheets, baked goods tend to stick to them.

The Good Cook’s non-stick design eliminates this issue without adding any nasty odors or fumes and is dishwasher safe for easy clean-up when you’re done.

Now you can enjoy making cookies with little stress knowing that every batch will come out perfect every time.

2. G & S Metal Products Company ProBake 

g & s metal products company probake 

Strong and sturdy, the ProBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet is ideal for baking cookies.

With its high-performance Teflon Xtra nonstick coating, it can easily withstand the wear and tear of daily use.

Cooking sprays, oils, and paper liners are unnecessary because the nonstick finish releases food easily and makes cleanup a breeze.

The sheet doesn’t discolor or warp over time. This cookie sheet can withstand temperatures up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit, which means you can safely bake gourmet dinner party cookies without worrying about them burning during the last few minutes of baking.

ProBake bakeware is made with professional heavy-gauge steel, ensuring even heating with no hot spots, so you get the best baking results every time.

And it’s proud in the USA. The ProBake Nonstick Medium Cookie Pan has a 15.4” x 10.3” x 0.7” inner space and can hold up to about 37 oz.

of food, which for this pan is enough for 12 regular sized cookie halves, or about 24-25 mini-sized ones or 12 muffins or 18 mini muffins and just to give you a sense of size you could fit a 9-10 inch round cake into the mold, gives space of 2-3 inches around so anything larger please be mindful.

This pan’s dimensions are 16.91″ x 10.71″ with an external perimeter of 17.39″. There will be very little fuss when the food is released from the pan.

It is made from professional weight steel construction, which means that each piece is even and neutral, ensuring that there are no hot spots within the pan which may lead to uneven roasting or burning when working with the pan.

3. Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 3, Stainless Steel 

wildone baking sheet set of 3, stainless steel 

For making a variety of awesome baked goods, This 3-Piece Baking Set is the perfect fit.

The three baking sheets are not just excellent at conducting heat, they’re also made from heavy gauge aluminum and come with sturdy construction that allows them to be durable.

They feature nice black color so they look stylish in your home.

The non-stick surface can enhance your workspace and make sure the food will come out easily without being stuck in the pan.

These baking sheets fit most ovens better than traditional metal sheets do virtually eliminating messy cleanups.

Perfect for having fun cooking with kids or friends, which makes a great gift for family members or friends during the holidays.

The baking sheet is made of pure stainless steel rather than any other type of material. With this quality material, you won’t have to worry about it rusting or cracking under strain.

The stainless steel doesn’t retain heat from things like bowls or pots either, so it’s less likely that the food will stick to the sheet.

In addition to being easy to clean, a non-stick surface prevents food from getting stuck inside the crevices.

You can easily hand wash the sheet, and never use an abrasive sponge to clean it otherwise you risk scraping off its finish – something that could happen if there was a coating on top of it.

4. Good Cook AirPerfect 2-Pack Nonstick Cookie Sheets

good cook airperfect 2 pack nonstick cookie sheets

Bring the GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick Cookie Sheet Set to your home kitchen to ensure a delicious result every time.

Made of heavy-duty materials, these two cookie sheets are designed with larger and medium-sized batches in mind.

They include non-stick surfaces that help cupcakes, muffins, and more slip off easily while being baked, making clean-up quick and easy while they ensure you get the perfect bake for your favorite recipes.

With the no-burn insulation that is nestled between two layers of this innovative product, hot air circulates to ensure even heating and fewer instances of scorching. Made from premium grade nonstick carbon steel material, the pan resists warping during usage.

The large cookie pan measures 16″ x 14″ and the medium cookie pan measures 14″ x 12.” making sure you always have only the right size on hand when baking.

GoodCook as a company has continued to stay relevant by continually adding new features and enhancements to its products.

Proud to say that GoodCook is used in kitchens across America, and our name is recognized as a helpful resource supplying recipes, inspiration, and products for home cooks everywhere.

5. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick 

wilton perfect results premium non stick 

If you’ve got mixing bowls, measuring spoons, and a whisk, chances are you have the essential kitchen tools needed to create bakery treats! It’s time to upgrade your bakeware.

With our Wilton Mega stainless steel cookie sheet pan, you won’t need to worry about ruined treats or burning cookies at the bottom of the oven ever again.

You’ll be baking with confidence knowing that nothing will stick to this baking sheet and cleanup at the end of your baking day is a snap.

And thanks to its 9 ½ by 13-inch size, it’s perfect for recipes that serve 8-12 family members so you’ll be prepared when it comes to feeding a crowd.

Wilton mega Cookie sheets are a practical basic and must-have for busy home cooks. They help you make and serve the perfect cookies, but they can also enhance your cooking in more subtle ways too such as when it comes to plating meals.

Wilton offers some great non-stick cookie sheets that were created for baking in mind but that can be used for any other cooking task like plating meals. With their measurements of 15 x 21 inches, these practical items are extremely useful.

They are completely dishwasher safe but still, it might be best to hand wash them right before using or right after at least once a week so they will always be as good as new.

These cookie sheets feature a 10-year limited warranty that protects your investment in case of anything likely to happen during this time period.

6. TeamFar Baking Sheet with Rack Set

teamfar baking sheet with rack set

TeamFar Stainless Steel Baking Sheet Cookie Sheets Baking Pans and Cooling Rack Set are made of high-quality pure stainless steel. No worries about toxins getting into your food.

TeamFar baking sheets and rack are made of high-quality pure stainless steel, which means no more scraped burned pans or trips to the recycle station for you.

The superior mirror finish of both baking sheets and grill racks is easy, effortless cleanup. No one wants burned-on cookies stuck to their cookie sheet, so these newly developed TeamFar grills/baking racks solve that problem.

Those aren’t any problems you will have to deal with! Obviously, this product is constructed from the best materials available. It will be very durable and will last for quite some time as it is composed of high-quality materials.

The sheet is made of stainless steel, which is stain-resistant. The cookie pan itself has a mirror finish that stays shiny and effortlessly releases food, while the rack quickly cleans up as well without any additional scrubbing.

Both the cookie sheet and wire cooling rack can go in the dishwasher to save you time on cleaning up later.

The set includes three different size pans (16″x12″, 12″x9.5″, and 9″x7″) so that you have an option depending on what you are needing at the present moment. It can work as a standby baking pan or toaster oven pan that everyone will love year-round.



Are aluminum cookie sheets better?

Professional bakers prefer baking sheet pans because they heat up quickly and cool down evenly.

They’re made of aluminum, which transfers heat rapidly and will also allow you to gauge temperatures more easily.

Heat conducts through aluminum extremely well so the coldness from your refrigerator travels all the way up to the red-hot oven without any problems. This property is called thermal conductivity.

Do cookie sheets make a difference?

In terms of performance, it is nearly impossible to distinguish between the two designs of cookie sheets.

If there are obstacles preventing even air circulation around the oven/cookware area, a cookie sheet should be no larger than your oven is capable of accommodating, since heat will be distributed more efficiently if there are no obstacles.


Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports. In any case, bakeware is a necessity for industry professionals including cookie bakers and pastry chefs.

Cookie sheets are available in different varieties but some that are most popular are those made from lightweight aluminum or steel, depending on the material derived from which they were manufactured.

If you know you’re going to be making cookies on them a lot or if you happen to own an array of them at your business, it might be worth thinking about buying dark-colored cookie sheets instead as they tend to brown or burn cookies more evenly.

Related Guides